Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce
Click here to login e-Club  Click here to visit our Chinese frontpage

From the Chairman

Inside Legco

From the CEO

Cover Story

Giving Industrial Buildings New Life


Special Features 
Property Market
Gains Momentum


O'Rear's View 
A Second Plaza Accord?


China Economic Update

RMB, Export Tax Rebates Under Pressure

Business
Trade in Goods: Zero Tariff

CEPA Stimulates Co-operation

CEPA: Answers to Your Questions

Hong Kong -- Still a Fantastic Place for Business

Unleashing
Organisational Intelligence


Out of Stock

Caltex Oil Hong Kong

Chamber Programmes
Chamber Programmes

Chamber Visits
Modern Terminals


2003 Hong Kong
Eco-Business Awards Launched


Chamber
Happy Hour -- July


Chamber in Action


ARCHIVES

2010 Issues
2009 Issues
2008 Issues
2007 Issues
2006 Issues
2005 Issues
2004 Issues
2003 Issues
2002 Issues
2001 Issues
2000 Issues
1999 Issues

Search for

 
Advanced Search

SUBSCRIBE TO THE BULLETIN TODAY!

O'REAR'S VIEW                                                 September 2003 Issue


theBulletin.gif (2057 bytes)


A Second Plaza Accord?

The U.S. is threatening to export its economic woes at the risk of repeating the horrific policy failure of 1985, writes DAVID O'REAR

The U.S. economy is facing enormous imbalances, and there is a rising sense that China's renminbi will be the scapegoat. Two years after recession, real GDP growth is less than half of the rate seen in previous post-war slumps. Unemployment is higher than normal, despite interest rates and inflation at a 40-year low. Exports should be rising about 14 percent, but are actually contracting on an annualised basis. The parts of the economy usually ready to take off at this point -- such as consumer demand, investment and imports -- are starting to fade.

In the run-up to next year's presidential election, there is a very real risk that Washington will look abroad for a quick fix, and that would derail Hong Kong's nascent recovery. Our own first-half slump was SARS-driven, with trade the sole beacon of hope. That critical driver -- three times as important as domestic demand -- is now under threat. The threat is not just the slow U.S. recovery, but also the possible repeat of a horrific policy failure from 1985.

Washington is steeling itself to devalue the dollar much further than has happened to date, and China is being set up as the fall guy.

The U.S. imbalances are getting dangerous. The trade deficit requires US$1.5 billion a day in foreign financing, half again as much as the previous record under Ronald Reagan. The fiscal shortfall, expected to top 5 percent of GDP, is not far below the 20-year-old record.

The last time things looked this bad, the rich nations felt they had to act against the strong dollar.

orear.jpg (24593 bytes)The ugly twins

The so-called twin deficits, trade and fiscal, are a near duplicate of the conditions that led to the Plaza Accord. In September 1985, the U.S., U.K., France, Germany and Japan sat down to reengineer the world's main exchange rates. That agreement saw the dollar fall by half against other major currencies. The result set in place the conditions that caused the Japanese bubble to expand and burst, damaging that economy for more than a decade.

Their goal was to stimulate demand outside the U.S. -- and most particularly in Japan -- to help the world's largest economy reduce its dangerous imbalances. In that they were successful: in real terms, growth in Japanese imports rose from an average of 1.6 percent a year in 1983-85 to 11.3 percent in 1986-88. At the same time, U.S. imports slowed, from 14.5 percent per annum to 6.1 percent a year.

One side effect of this tinkering was to drive down inflation in the then-European Economic Community (now the EU) from 5.9 percent a year in the three years prior to the Plaza Accords to just 2.8 percent. Germany and Japan ran a real risk of deflation in the process, as their average annual rates of household inflation slowed to just 0.4 percent and 0.6 percent, respectively, in 1986-88.

If any of this sounds familiar, substitute China for Japan, and 2003 for 1985. The key factors are in place for a repeat of the disastrous (for Japan) Plaza Accord. The U.S. is feeling tough and aggressive; the economy is out of kilter; unemployment is high and rising; the budget has more red ink than a paint factory; and a single Asian nation is being set up to take the blame. It looks like 1985 all over again.

The differences, however, are critical. First, Chinese imports rose nearly 43 percent in the first seven months of this year and more than 20 percent per annum in the previous four years. This is no under-performer. Second, consumer prices have fallen in three of the past five years, and even when rising have not topped 1 percent since 1997. A sharp appreciation of the renminbi would drive China back into deflation. Third, China is far poorer than Japan was in the mid-1980s, and cannot afford to take the risks associated with exchange rate manipulation. The country needs to create tens of millions of jobs every year, and the star performer is exports.

If Japan's mature financial institutions and exporting corporations were devastated by the aftermath of the first Plaza Accord, imagine what would happen to China's far less developed banks and other financial sector companies. The implications for Hong Kong are severe as well.

Implications for Hong Kong

Our domestic economy has been hammered but trade is doing very well. Two-way commerce, in the 12 months to end-June, was the largest in history, as was our trade with the rest of China. The key factor today is whether trade will remain strong enough to turn Hong Kong's recovery into sustainable growth.

Two-way trade is three times larger than our domestic economy, and every previous recession but one was caused by slumping demand abroad. The reverse is also true: Hong Kong has never had a recession when trade was strong. In 1974-75, 1998-99 and again in 2000-01, the drop in foreign trade pushed Hong Kong into recession. The only exception was in 1985, when growth in trade remained positive.

What would another Plaza Accord mean for Hong Kong? If the renminbi appreciates sufficiently to curb the American appetite for imports, growth in China will slump. Exports will fall and imports barely grow at all. That will hit Hong Kong's trade, hard. Further, the 43 percent of our imports that comes from the rest of China should rise in price. While a little inflation might sound good just now, there would be no corresponding pick-up in our own economic activity.

The U.S. needs to address its own problems, primarily the reckless budget deficit, before looking off-shore for solutions. And, Hong Kong needs to keep its powder dry.

David O'Rear is the Chamber's Chief Economist. He can be reached at david@chamber.org.hk


Click here to contact the Editor...
Send Your Feedback


  China Breakfast Roundtable: 2010 NPC & CPPCC Annual Sessions Review

  "Corporate Architects" Series... Proudly presented by the HKGCC Women Executives Club, RBS Coutts and the Financial Times: Luncheon with Ms Christine Loh, CEO and Co-Founder, Civic Exchange

  Cultural Extravaganza cum Cocktail Reception Featuring Consulates General of the Americas Region in Hong Kong: Canada, Colombia, Mexico and the United States of America

  HKGCC China Committee Working Mission to Beijing and Tianjin

  Enhancing Cost Effectiveness Through Energy and Carbon Reduction

More >>

past events
Winning the Talent War -- The 8 Essentials

Kerry Larkan, a leading Australian author, keynote speaker, commentato... details>>

EU Trade Policy after the Lisbon Treaty

Helena Konig, Trade Directorate-General, European Commission, spoke at... details>>

Luncheon with the Financial Secretary John Tsang

HKSAR Financial Secretary John Tsang elaborated on his latest Budget a... details>>

Can Asia-Pacific Economies Save the Doha Round?

Five years after WTO members convened in Hong Kong, the Doha Round is ... details>>

Chocolate to Melt Your Heart

Ten lucky members had the opportunity on February 11 to make their own... details>>

more >>

About HKGCC | Member Services | Join Us | Contact Us | Advertising | Jobs
The Chamber's Privacy Policy Statement
Copyright © 1998-2010 The Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce. All Rights Reserved.