WTO
September 2000 Issue
the bulletin
The Myriad of Structures in
the WTO
What kind of body will China be joining when its WTO
membership is accepted? A club of 139 members, or more specifically a club with 139 member
governments. An institution peopled by bureaucrats, the WTO ??s goal in life is to establish rules and structures. No wonder the
WTO itself is designed as a complicated web of structures.
The highest authority of the WTO is the Ministerial Conference. According to the WTO
constitution, a Ministerial Conference must be held at least once every two years. The
last one took place in Seattle in December 1999; that makes November 2001 the deadline for
the next ministerial.
After China joins the WTO, MOFTEC Minister Shi Guangsheng will be the minister
representing China. For Hong Kong the ministerial equivalent is Secretary for Commerce and
Industry T H Chau.
Between Ministerial Conferences the regular business of the WTO is undertaken by trade
negotiators. Every member designates a senior official as the Chief Negotiator ?V in the case of Hong Kong it is Director
General of Trade and Industry Mr Joshua Law. For China it should be Assistant Minister
Long Yongtu.
For many WTO members, the Chief Negotiator is only an occasional visitor. The
day-to-day negotiation is handled by a team of resident representatives at WTO's
headquarters in Geneva. Typically, these representatives carry ambassadorial rank. Hong
Kong ??s Chief Representative is
Stuart Harbinson. For China, hitherto the representative in Geneva is Ambassador Qiao
Zonghuai, who oversees China??s
relationship with all United Nations and international bodies in Geneva. After WTO entry,
the likelihood is that another ambassador may be appointed to take charge of the WTO
specifically.
In Geneva, the 137 resident delegations to the WTO conduct their businesses through
participation in the complex structure under the WTO organisation. At the top of the
structure is the General Council. It works like a general assembly of WTO delegates and as
the Dispute Settlement Body, similar to that of an arbitration court. It also works as the
Trade Policy Review Body, a kind of audit department on the trade policy regimes of WTO
members. The top three are then followed by three Councils on Trade in Goods, Trade
Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPs), and Trade in Services, each of
which corresponds to a treaty under the WTO. Together these are the big six of the WTO ??s committee structure.
A few standing committees exist on environment, development, regional trade agreement
and balance of payment, reflecting WTO members ?? concern on pollution issues, on developing countries, trade blocs
and investment flows. There is also a housekeeping committee on budget and finance.
Any number of working groups can be formed to examine topical issues of interest to WTO
members. Of particular importance are the working groups on competition policy and
investment. If working groups succeed to bring these subjects into the negotiating agenda,
they may well evolve into standing committees like the one on Trade and Environment.
Under each of the Councils for Trade in Goods and Trade in Services are various
committees and working groups ?V there
are 12 under the Council for Trade in Goods. Of these the Committee on Trade in
Agriculture is the most contentious, but other committees on various aspects such as
anti-dumping and rules of origin are also very popular negotiating forums.
China will therefore be joining not just a club, but a myriad of committees and working
groups within the WTO. It will have the freedom to join or be active in as many committees
as it wishes. As a member it will also have the opportunity to contest ?V usually by negotiation, not election ?V for chairmanship of some of these bodies.
?@
|