SPECIAL FEATURE
October 2003 Issue

Going Paperless
Preparing for the good times with efficient online trade
transactions: The case of TAL Apparel.
By ROSS MILBURN
Hong Kong's incomparable reputation as a great trading city may have taken
a knock in the present recession, but as the saying goes: "When the going gets tough,
the tough get going," and despite the belt tightening, our pioneering spirit is still
at work.
Enterprising managers are now preparing for the next era of business
expansion, and that means focusing on two key areas. Firstly, we must maintain R&D
expenditure by continuing to satisfy and exceed customer expectations on quality and
price. Secondly, we must make every effort to increase the efficiency of our operational
systems.
At this particular time, the crucial area for profitable investment in new
systems is in the B2B supply chain. For years, Hong Kong's trading companies have
shouldered a huge cost burden associated with their global trading transactions, in the
form of paper trade documents, L/C fees, huge amounts of data entry, data errors between
trade partners, delayed payments, and a lack of visibility on the status of trade
transactions associated with export consignments.
Reducing transaction costs
Efforts to reduce these costs have been going on since the 1970s, when EDI
(electronic data interchange) was introduced to take some of the documents online. EDI has
pointed the way forward, but it requires each trading company to install special software
to translate its documents, which are transmitted on an expensive, dedicated network. A
lot of management effort is required to negotiate and utilise special message formats.
During the dotcom era, efforts focused on online exchanges that could
execute EDI on a cheaper basis, but most of the vendors were too small and inexperienced
to attract big customers. Other systems were designed by banks, but these were limited in
functionality, and were tied too closely to each bank's customers to form the basis of a
standard trading system.
The learning curve, however, has paid off. It is now possible for any Hong
Kong company, together with all its supply chain partners -- customers, suppliers, banks,
insurance companies and logistics vendors -- to join an online trading community that cuts
the cost of trade transactions, at little upfront cost, and with complete security.
Most trading companies want an end-to-end solution starting from
procurement and request-to-quote, through the purchase order, shipping documents,
invoices, compliance, and settlement. And the whole online process has to be visible to
the trading partners, from any Internet PC.
TAL Apparel goes online
One Hong Kong company that recently took its buying and selling
transactions online is TAL Apparel Limited, a world-leader in global garment manufacturing
and a long-standing member of the Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce.
TAL Apparel has long leveraged technology to gain an advantage in
business. Continual investment in R&D has resulted in innovations that include patents
for non-iron, non-wrinkle shirts, and the De-Odorant technology, which protects textiles
against bacteria and fungi.
In 2002, TAL Apparel adopted an online system from TradeCard to automate
buying and selling transactions with its supply chain partners. Any purchase order can be
negotiated online, and once this document has been entered into the system, most of the
data in it can be reused without re-keying in subsequent documents, such as invoices and
statements, payment authorization, shipping documents, insurance, and inspection reports.
The new system incorporates an online compliance engine that can be
substituted for paper-based bank L/Cs, and this paperless system is used for more than
half the dollar volume of L/C purchases -- all but the smallest suppliers use it. This
cuts transaction costs, and the main reason is not the saving of bank charges, but the
elimination of paper documents, explained Ruth Kan, Financial Controller at TAL.
"Typically, there are ten pages of documents for each L/C and often
amendments add another four to five pages. We have estimated that a full set of documents
for a transaction may cost US$250 to prepare and process," she said.
For international trade, TAL now has access to multiple providers of
credit coverage, including a major Hong Kong bank with which it has a long-standing
relationship, and which can now issue electronic L/Cs. Paper has been eliminated from the
L/C process, but TAL still benefits from the L/C credit line provided by its main bank.
The bank also benefits, because it now has access to a substantial online trading
community, just as the number of global online trade transactions is skyrocketing.
Online benefits
"Our suppliers are happy that, whatever country they are in, they
have instant visibility into the progress of each transaction," Ms Kan said, adding
that the online system makes payments faster. "Using bank L/Cs, payment takes four
weeks, but online payments take two weeks. For SMEs (Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises)
and small suppliers, it is very important to get paid quickly and to turn the money around
faster. Most of our largest suppliers have adopted the online system and are benefiting.
If our buyers adopt the system, we get paid faster, too."
Dr Harry Lee, Managing Director, TAL Apparel Limited, said an Internet
based system is more cost-effective than the alternatives. "Previously with some of
our U.S. customers such as JC Penney, we used EDI over an expensive private network. Since
mid-2002, JC Penney has been using TradeCard, which runs on the web, and this could lower
costs significantly," he said.
As well as providing greater efficiency, working online makes management
easier.
"Putting the transactions online is only the first step. The next
question is how we use the reports and data generated by the system to analyze the
business and discover underlying trends and obtain detailed costs," Dr Lee said.
"As all our documents go electronic, this benefit will be even greater. The online
system also enables us to communicate with our buyers more effectively, especially in case
of problems or delays."
TAL's recently acquired ERP system from Intentia -- a major strategic
investment -- will be linked with TradeCard to provide seamless communication between TAL
and its trade partners on the financial supply chain, and more complete automation of
transactions. The ERP system will be able to break down orders received from buyers and
convert them into multiple raw material orders to suppliers. It is hoped to convert all
documents, including invoices, packing lists and bills of lading, into online documents
and to integrate them with the Intentia ERP system within a year.
Online transaction compliance is much cheaper than the paper L/C bank
charge of about US$150 of issuing fees, Ms Kan said. "When we can fully link this to
our ERP system, the savings will be even more significant in other areas," she says.
When trading partners go online, they benefit from using standard systems,
Dr Lee said. "TradeCard is the trade transaction management platform of the future
that could even form part of the e-government initiative in Hong Kong." |