O'REAR'S VIEW
May 2003 Issue

It could be (much) worse
The atypical pneumonia outbreak came at a relatively good time for the
SAR economy, writes DAVID O'REAR
Hong Kong's economy is in the doldrums, once again. While this year's
reason is 70 percent pneumonia and 30 percent structural, the externalities -- factors
outside our economy -- are actually quite favourable, at least for now.
According to the International Monetary Fund's (IMF) World Economic
Outlook, published in April, global GDP is forecast to rise 3.2 percent this year and 4.1
percent in 2004, the fastest growth since 2000. The world economy is thought to be
expanding a healthy 3 percent in the first half of this year, and ever so slightly faster
in July-December. A year from now, in January-June 2004, global GDP is forecast to be
rising at a 3.8 percent clip, picking up speed later in the year. Forecasts for segments
of the world -- the rich nations, Asia and of course, Hong Kong and the rest of China --
vary from one economist to the next (we never all agree on anything), but the general
trend is far from grim.
Hong Kong's fortunes closely track those of the world economy, rising more
rapidly when global growth -- and particularly growth in trade -- rises, and dipping
during global slumps. In the second half of 2002, the global economy is estimated to have
grown nearly 3.5 percent, which coincides with Hong Kong's return to positive growth. As
the first graph shows, our economy rises and falls with the world's fortunes.
Atypical pneumonia changes some of that, but not all. We are losing
economic activity in the tourism, restaurants and retail sector at an alarming rate, but
trade -- which is equal to nearly three times the size of our domestic economy -- remains
robust. The concern now is over perceptions, as well as patients. If we are seen to be
paralysed, the lag between controlling the epidemic and economic recovery will stretch out
unnecessarily.
Trade plays a critical role in our economy, and when world trade is on
the up-swing, Hong Kong prospers. In 2001, global trade had its worst year in more than a
decade, and as a result Hong Kong's two-way trade (we make money both ways) contracted 1.8
percent. Last year, world trade expanded 2.5 percent, according to the World Trade
Organisation (WTO), and the HKSAR saw an 8.1 percent growth in international commerce. The
IMF expects trade to rise 4.3 percent in 2003 and 6.1 percent next year, setting the
foundations for strong growth -- at least in that critical sector -- here at home.
Five Asian neighbours -- Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore and the
Mainland of China -- accounted for 61.7 percent of Hong Kong's two-way trade last year.
Their transactions with the world increased 7.6 percent in 2002 over the previous year,
and laid the foundation for Hong Kong's strong trade performance. This year, the trade of
these five economies -- combined imports and exports -- is up 27 percent in the first
quarter, over January-March 2002. Clearly, any increase of this magnitude must bode well
for Hong Kong's own commerce, although, the impact of the atypical pneumonia epidemic must
be taken into account. The USA is the other major trading partner, and while first quarter
data are not yet available, the 9.9 percent growth in two-way trade in January-February,
over the same 2002 period, is strong.
The second graph shows the correlation between global trade and that of
Hong Kong. What cannot be shown is how soon quality assurance teams will feel comfortable
enough to return to inspecting factories in the Pearl River Delta, buyers will come to
trade shows and orders for winter fashions and Christmas toys will start coming in.
Hong Kong's close proximity to the source of the pneumonia outbreak may
raise questions about the wisdom of deeper integration with the Pearl River Delta, or
indeed, about globalisation itself. As businesses, we need to fight this perception.
Foreign-invested factories in Guangdong, for the most part, are among the best in China in
terms of worker safety and hygiene. Hong Kong-based employees are a huge part of the
travel across the boundary, and yet the main sources of concern are housing estates and
hospitals. These are critical messages that we should be communicating with our trading
partners.
As for globalisation, it should be obvious that the presence of
international investors in the Pearl River Delta is one of the main reasons that it is the
most prosperous part of the nation. We, as businesses, are directly responsible for
dramatically raising the standards of living of millions of people. These people are not
just our workers (or shareholders), but also associated businesses such as suppliers, the
employees of those businesses, and the families of everyone involved. Because of our
presence, millions of people eat better, have improved access to medical treatment, live
longer and have a greater opportunity to educate their children. Their working conditions
are vastly improved, their ability to compete in the world is enhanced and their prospects
for a better future assured.
Getting our business partners to recognise the true picture of the risks
of doing business here requires that we balance the picture presented in the media. There
are risks, but they are not higher than those associated with "normal"
pneumonia. There are also rewards, particularly for those who work with Hong Kong and the
rest of China when others will not. Perhaps the greatest risk is to do nothing, and allow
hysteria to spread.
David O'Rear is the Chamber's Chief
Economist. He can be reached at david@chamber.org.hk |