CHINA ECONOMIC UPDATE
May 2003
Issue

Institutional reforms to drive China's
market economy
Several ministerial-level bodies have been set up in China to replace
once key ministries. RUBY ZHU analyses what changes businesses can expect to see as a result and
their possible impact on China's market-oriented reforms
The end of the Tenth National People's Congress saw the start of a new
round of government restructuring in China. The changes involve the creation of several
ministerial-level bodies, including the Ministry of Commerce (MOC), State Asset Management
Commission (SAMC), State Development and Reform Commission (SDRC) and China Banking
Regulatory Commission (CBRC). The changes have been a cause of concern to the Hong Kong
business community. This article analyses changes to the role that the Chinese Government
plays in these departments and their possible impact on China's market-oriented reforms.
The former Ministry of Foreign Trade and Economic Cooperation (MOFTEC),
and the State Economic and Trade Commission (SETC) have been dismantled and their work has
been incorporated into the new Ministry of Commerce (MOC). Many countries worldwide unify
the management of internal and foreign trade under a single department, such as Japan's
Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry and the U.S. Department of Commerce.
MOC's establishment aims to integrate China's domestic and foreign trade,
and fulfil China's WTO commitments, which include granting all Mainland enterprises
trading rights by the end of 2004. It also removes any previously overlapping functions
among government agencies and is more in-line with international practices.
MOFTEC used to manage affairs related to foreign investments and was a key
office for foreign businesses. Since the old ministry was responsible for formulating
foreign investment policies and approving major projects, foreign investors are naturally
concerned about how MOC will operate.
The State Council has appointed Lu Fuyuan as the new minister to drive
MOC, and its main responsibilities are: perfecting a market system, monitoring commodities
demand and supply, organising international economic co-operation and co-ordinating
matters relating to anti-dumping and anti-subsidies.
In this writer's opinion, formulating foreign investment policies will be
a key function of MOC. Two of its most pressing issues are, firstly, the export tax
refund. Some Mainland cities have not yet paid back foreign businesses for the export tax
paid for 2001, which is causing cash flow problems for many of them. Its second pressing
issue is it needs to draw up detailed policy guidelines for foreign investors' engaging in
merger and acquisition activities in China.
The former State Development Planning Commission has been reorganised into
the State Development and Reform Commission (SDRC), which is headed by Ma Kai from the
former Structural Reform Office. The role of the SDRC remains relatively unchanged,
although some of its work has been incorporated into the MOC.
With energy issues growing in importance in China, a new Energy Bureau has
been set up. As defined by the State Council, the SDPC is responsible for the
comprehensive study and formulation of policies on economic and social development, and
for guiding reform of the macro economic system. Its "planning" role has been
diluted as it has relaxed its grip on commodity prices, which further indicates that China
is moving away from a planned economy.
Li Rongrong, former minister of the State Economic and Trade Commission,
has been appointed the leader of the newly-created State Asset Management Commission
(SAMC). The responsibilities of this new body are: representing China to perform its
duties as an investor as authorised by the State Council, supervising state-owned assets,
increasing the value of such assets and strengthening state-owned operations.
The establishment of SAMC is an important step towards reforming
state-owned enterprises (SOEs). Previously, SOEs were owned by the "state,"
which is an abstract concept. Now, they have a specific "boss" -- SAMC. This
initiative helps separate politics from business. With their goodwill and long history,
SOEs remain the preferred partners for many foreign investors in China. But since the
Central Government did not distinguish clearly the responsibilities and rights of SOEs in
the past, foreign investors always suffered when disputes arose.
The problem of exactly who owns SOEs' assets has existed for several
decades. It is difficult to straighten out the intricate relationships between
enterprises, local governments and the Central Government over the short term.
Consequently, it will take some time for SAMC to become the SOEs' real "boss."
Following the establishment of the China Security Regulatory Commission
and the China Insurance Regulatory Commission, the long-awaited China Banking Regulatory
Commission (CBRC) has been set up. The People's Bank of China's role in supervising and
regulating banks and other financial institutions will be separated and integrated with
the related functions of the Central Financial Working Commission. Liu Mingkang, from the
People's Bank of China, has been appointed founding chairman of the CBRC.
Most countries that have experienced financial crises have separated their
monetary policies from financial supervision. To cope with the Asian Financial Crisis,
China set up the Central Financial Committee in 1998 to co-ordinate the nation's finances
and supervise all financial sectors. The move was in-line with the rising trend of foreign
financial institutions entering China, especially after China's WTO accession, which
required China separate its monetary policies from the supervision of its banks.
However, under Chinese Banking Law, the supervision of banks and other
financial institutions falls under the responsibility of the People's Bank of China. As
the above changes require amendments to the law to be made, the CBRC is the last body to
start operations under the restructuring plan.
China's institutional reforms clearly show that the country is taking
positive steps towards becoming a market economy. The State Council has, in general,
followed the example of free market economies to restructure and redefine the function of
its government agencies -- measures which will boost foreign investors' confidence in
China.
Although China, as a developing country, cannot expect its economy to
become as open and free as Hong Kong's, its reforms and the opening up of various sectors
are expected to enhance Hong Kong's role as China's most international city.
Ruby Zhu is the Chamber's Assistant Economist. She can be reached at, ruby@chamber.org.hk |