For Hong
Kong, the 4.5 percent year-on-year rise in first-quarter real GDP exceeded most
expectations. However, that respectable headline figure was driven entirely by collapsing
prices and booming trade. Domestic demand contracted once again, for the 6th straight
quarter, by 0.2 percent while two-way trade rose 16.9 percent. In nominal terms, the
economy fell 0.4 percent, while the quarter-to-quarter annualised figures, when available,
will say we hit recession in Q-2.
The only bright spot was trade: over four months, China accounted for more
than half of the 15.2 percent increase in Hong Kong's global two-way trade. Re-exports
rose 17.8 percent, again driven by China (up 29.2 percent) and to a lesser extent, Japan
(up 14 percent). Imports rose 15.2 percent from January-April 2002, also led by China (up
12.7 percent) and Japan (up 23.8 percent).
China trade is far more than just a bright spot. In the first five months
of the year, the Mainland's two-way trade with the world rose 39.6 percent over
January-May 2002, a pace that will go a long way toward easing our plight. The graph shows
the close correlation between growth in Hong Kong's two-way trade and in that of China,
and until recently, the knock-on effect to Hong Kong's domestic demand.
The outlook for demand elsewhere, however, is more likely to deteriorate
than to improve quickly. Japan revised downward growth in real imports in the first
quarter, from an initial 9.2 percent year-on-year expansion to just 7.4 percent. Much of
that modification stemmed from the elimination of all growth in capital investment, from a
2.3 percent rise to a mere 0.07 percent blip. Both measures of economic activity --
imports and investment -- are drivers of economic output across East Asia.
But it is in the local economy that the clouds are darkest, and will only
slowly clear. Domestic demand remains in the doldrums -- as it has for the past 18 months
-- as residents stayed away from shops and restaurants in droves, and tourists simply
stayed away. Private consumption, down 2.1 percent in the January-March period from a year
earlier, deteriorated from the previous two quarters. In nominal terms, the HK$270 billion
first quarter domestic economy is exactly the same size as in the second quarter of 1995,
eight years ago, and more than 24 percent smaller than at the 4th quarter 1997 peak.
SARS and the consequent collapse in tourism hit the local economy very
hard. Retail sales in the first quarter were off 2.6 percent from a year earlier, and then
fell 15.2 percent in April. We are now back to 1992 shopping levels in dollar terms, and
1993 prices. Even before the worst of SARS, business receipts at hotels and airlines were
already off more than 22 percent in January-March, from the same 2002 period.
April numbers give us a good guess at how bad May might have been, and
with early signs for June, a view on the second quarter. Aside from restaurants,
entertainment and tourist spending -- which are not separated from the retail figures --
the largest declines in the month were in the clothing, shoes and durable goods
categories, comprising nearly 40 percent of the total drop in sales. The jewellery,
watches, clocks and valuable gifts category accounted for 23 percent of the slump. Neither
is likely to have done any better in May, but recovery in June is expected.
The first quarter's rapid, 4.7 percent drop in prices (as measured by the
GDP deflator), was the quickest decline since mid-2000 and the 19th straight drop in a
row. Deflation has worsened each quarter in the past year, and deep price cutting in the
April-June quarter suggests the end is not yet in sight.
The good news is that various governments and health organisations are
recognising that SARS is not a threat to travellers to Hong Kong, given the city's
new-found attention to hygiene. Visitors from Guangdong are returning, and the lifting of
the U.S. State Department's travel restrictions on government employees further confirms
that the worst is (touch wood) over. At this writing, news of completion of the SAR's
discussions with Mainland authorities over the Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement
(CEPA) is still pending, but the announcement in late June is expected to give a boost to
business, investment and morale.
David O'Rear is the Chamber's Chief Economist. He can be reached at david@chamber.org.hk