Economic data show that the worst looks to be over for Hong Kong, but
it will take some time before the upswing begins to be felt, writes DAVID O'REAR
Hong Kong's economy is showing strong signs that the bottom of the
business cycle is either just past or just about to pass. The evidence is strongest in
three areas: retail sales, price deflation and employment. Let's look at each in turn.
Retail sales in Hong Kong dipped less than HK$400 million in October and
November, from a year earlier, the smallest declines in quite a while (the average for the
previous six months was nearly double: HK$787 million a month). Clearly, the numbers are
heading in the right direction.
In volume terms, the October-November figures also looked less bad,
falling only about half as much as in April-September. The specific components of the
retail sector paint a different picture. Fuel was off 15 per cent in volume in November,
jewelry and similar items 12.1 per cent, apparel 9.5 per cent and furniture and fixtures
8.9 per cent. Increases were evident in motor vehicles and parts (up 21.4 per cent), also
in volume terms -- the fifth straight month of increase -- and electrical and photographic
merchandise 7.2 per cent. This suggests the luxury market is healthy, and the declines are
primarily in commodities. This is confirmed by the discrepancy between rising sales at
supermarket outlets in department stores (up 1.5 per cent in November and 1.2 per cent
over 11 months) and the more modest 0.3 per cent rise (0.9 per cent in January-November),
in direct supermarket purchases.
As for prices, Hong Kong's fifth year of deflation is likely to be its
last, at least in this economic cycle. It will, however, take some time for prices to
stabilize, as seen in the latest figures. The Composite Consumer Price Index fell 3.6 per
cent in November from a year earlier, and probably about the same (perhaps a hair less) in
December. That would give us an average decline of 3.2 per cent for the year.
Utilities (gas, water and electricity) fell in price the furthest last
year -- over 7 per cent -- followed by durable goods and housing. The price of alcohol and
tobacco products actually rose by nearly 2.5 per cent, and clothing and footwear by about
0.8 per cent.
Mathematically, continued deep deflation will boost full-year real GDP
figures as the change is prices -- in this case, negative -- is subtracted from nominal
GDP growth. For example, a nominal 2 per cent growth in the economy, combined with a 3 per
cent drop in prices would yield 5 per cent real growth: (+2 minus -3 = +5).
The full-year Composite CPI deflation, while not strictly comparable to
the broader GDP deflator, is one of the early signs for higher-than-anticipated real GDP
growth in the fourth quarter.
What is important to remember, however, is that lower real GDP figures for
the fourth quarter might be a positive signal, a signal that Hong Kong's deflation is
easing.
As price deflation eases and the economy expands faster, more jobs will be
created. However, employment is a lagging indicator: companies tend to hire only when they
have more work than hands to do it, and then only when that work is predictably stable
over the foreseeable future.
We probably added about 33,000 jobs in the fourth quarter of 2002, and now
have more employment in Hong Kong than at any time in history. We also have more people
looking for jobs, because of strong growth in the labor pool, and that is what gives us
over 7 per cent unemployment.
The improvement in underemployment -- people who cannot find enough work
-- puts an even finer point on the turnaround. Subtracting underemployment from total
employment gives what might (for lack of a better term) be called "complete
employment." This figure rose 0.8 per cent year-on-year, the first improvement in 13
months.
David O'Rear is the Chamber's Chief Economist. He can be reached at david@chamber.org.hk,
or on 2823-1242.