COVER STORY
December 2002 Issue

Redefining HK's middleman
role
Once the pacesetter for investment into China, the SAR should
now be looking to guide the PRD's future development, says Mainland economist
Hong Kong has been blazing the trail of investment into China for much of
the country's opening door policy. Between 1979 and 1997, about US$120 billion, or 54 per
cent of total foreign investments pumped into China during the period flowed from Hong
Kong.
The SAR remains the leading source of FDI in China, with accumulative
investments from the territory last year reaching US$187 billion, despite a worldwide drop
in FDI of 50 per cent in 2001 -- the first fall in a decade and the worst in 30 years. The
weak global economy helps explain why FDI from Hong Kong between 1998 and 2001 dipped
slightly to account for 38.7 per cent of the US$67.1 billion total during the period.
Interestingly, China defied the global trend and its FDI last year grew 15 per cent to
reach US$46.8 billion. A total of 34 per cent, or US$16.7 billion, of that came from Hong
Kong.
Wang Zhile, director, Research Center on Transnational Corporations,
Chinese Academy of International Trade and Economic Cooperation, MOFTEC, believes the
falling percentage of investment from Hong Kong is due, in part, to businesses investing
directly in China, rather than taking the traditional Hong Kong route.
"Despite the general slowdown in FDI worldwide, investment in China
has been increasing at an average annual rate of 22 per cent. So I think there is some
reorganization and shuffling going on," he told the audience at the Chamber's China
Business Conference.
Because more businesses are setting up shop in China as wholly owned
foreign enterprises, they are investing more than they would as a joint venture, he said.
This is further evidenced by the rise in organizations setting up research and development
centers and regional headquarters there, he said.
"The significant change in type of investment and operation in China
shows foreign businesses believe that the Mainland market is maturing and that they can
move in by themselves, rather than having to find a partner," Mr Wang added.
China's entry into the World Trade Organization (WTO) is making
regulations more transparent. As a result, investment procedures in China are coming
closer to what Western firms are accustomed to and therefore feel they no longer need to
find a China savvy Hong Kong middleman.
The pace of development of major cities in China is accelerating this
trend, and because Hong Kong has changed little, Mr Wang reckons it is running the risk of
being left behind the Mainland's star cities.
"In the past, if Shanghai was moving ahead and Hong Kong was keeping
pace with the tempo, there was nothing to worry about, because the changes would create
more chances for both cities," he said.
But now that foreign firms are starting to believe that they no longer
need Hong Kong to hold their hand to bring them into China to invest their money, he
believes Hong Kong needs to redefine its role.
To articulate his point, he drew on quotes from business legend Jack
Welch:
"For an organization, if the pace of internal change is slower than
that of external change, the end is near. The only question is when."
"View reform as an incentive, an opportunity, but not a threat or
crisis."
He believes Hong Kong still has a pivotal role to play in China and
encourages the government and businesses to think out of the box.
Although the Pearl River Delta has been growing at breakneck pace for the
past decade, there is a dire lack of direction for the region. Mr Wang suggests the PRD
can learn a lesson from the way member nations of the European Union have joined forces to
increase their region's competitiveness and efficiency globally.
Instead of each city in the PRD racing to develop their own airport, sea
port and logistics centre, they should join forces to take advantage of each other's
benefits.
"If someone could address all these issues; give them a focus, the
region would benefit, and I think this is the role that Hong Kong should play," he
said. "After all, we are all in the same boat. If other countries are trying to take
a bigger share of the market in China, why aren't we trying to upgrade and coordinate
ourselves to take advantage of this?"
Next>>
Speeches>> |