COVER STORY
December 2002 Issue

What does the future hold
for China?
FDI is fuelling China's economic development, but it is also
creating a number of unique challenges that will have global consequences
China's economic reforms will speed up the development of the new,
commercial China, and totally alter the face of the global market and investment flows.
Some of the knock-on effects of these changes can be predicted, Robert
Broadfoot, managing director Political & Economic Risk Consultancy Ltd, told the
audience at the Chamber's China Business Conference on November 5. Other changes run the
gamut from "black hole" to "bonanza."
Some of the foreseeable changes include the shift in trade and investment
from Southeast Asian nations to China, which is expected to gain steam in the coming
years. Part of the shift is based on the perceived potential of the Mainland market, but
also, recent terrorist activities in Asia have made China seem like a much safer place to
do business.
Second, is that there are going to be more entry and exit points. Hong
Kong, which has long acted as the main door into China will, have to work harder to
attract business as more gateways are unlocked.
Business between Japan, Korea, Taiwan and China is expected to skyrocket
as huge investment flows in these areas start to change. As manufacturing shifts from
Japan and Korea to China, their trade balances with the United States and Europe will look
healthier. China, on the other hand, will have to deal with the net impact that its
growing surplus will have on its trading partners.
While most big companies tend to approach the China market as individual
markets by province, its entry into the WTO is expected to resolve many of the current
logistical problems, which will allow businesses to look at China as one big market, Mr
Broadfoot said.
The two biggest uncertainties in China, however, are to what extent will
foreign investors be allowed to access currently restricted sectors? And where is all that
invested capital going?
"A lot of people talk about how fast China is growing, but the big
question is who is making money? Where are the profits?" he asks.
"When you look at the growth, impressive as it is, you have to ask
what have you been doing with this money? So how do you invest it in a manner that will
earn an attractive return?"
For the future, Mr Broadfoot outlined a few scenarios. Many companies that
are investing in the Mainland believe that China is the greatest place to make money in
the world today, and if they are not there, they will lose out to their competitors, Mr
Broadfoot said. Moreover, as the country develops, companies believe they will make more
money.
"We call that our bonanza scenario," he said.
Another scenario is Jurassic park, in that China's current legal system
cannot be depended upon to resolve difficulties, so companies are content to just slog it
out. More often than not, it is the larger firms that win these battles.
The scenario that everyone is hoping will not happen is the black hole.
"What happens if China falls on its face?" he asks. "What
happens when so much of the money going into China is just wasted? There is an awful lot
of money that can be wasted, and as we saw with Enron, this money can just disappear. The
more that everyone is investing in China, the more worrying this can be, because this will
have global consequences."
Next>>
Speeches>> |