CHAMBER PROGRAMMES
December 2001 Issue

China driving Asia forward
The
Mainland is set to take up where Japan left off as the economic dynamo of Asia
China is going to end up teaching Asia how to run a capitalist system and
replace Japan as the business model that developing countries emulate to drive their
economies forward.
"A great historical shift is set to unfold in Asia, and China is at
the centre of that change," William
Overholt, executive director, Nomura International (Hong Kong), told the audience at the
Venture Capital Partnership Conference luncheon on November 1.
Japan instigated the last change, and the economic success it generated
led everyone up until a dozen years ago to study the Japanese business model.
The approach helped Japan grow rapidly, but it also created tremendous
waste of capital and inflated many bubbles. Unfortunately for countries that were
emulating Japan, certain sectors of their economies were also ballooning to bursting
point.
Then in 1997, they all burst together because the Japanese banks got into
trouble. To save themselves, they started pulling their money out of Asian economies,
which sent regional markets into a tailspin.
Just as Japan had created an economic miracle, it had also created an
economic disaster. But just over a decade ago, everyone was saying that the 21st century
was going to be the Asian century. Japan was going to be the leader and the yen was going
to be the currency of region. Asia seemed to have it all, the leadership, the money, the
prestige and the drive. Investors and the public are now tired of the lethargy in Japan
and it is about to lose its leadership role in Asia.
"Now people are saying, 'Look at how those Chinese are managing their
economy.' And suddenly, that aura
that surrounded Japanese economic management and conveyed international economic clout is
shifting to Beijing. Economic diplomacy is completely discredited in Japan today," he said.
However, China essentially has the same problems that hobbled Japan: its
banks are limping along, lifelong employment is considered a right, bubbles in certain
sectors of its economy are approaching bursting point, and its state-owned enterprises are
guzzling vast amounts of money.
The difference between China and Japan, however, is that the Chinese
government has handled the situation in much the same way a Western government would have
handled it.
The Central Government realised its military had to get out of business,
its financial sectors need to be reformed, its loss-making SOEs had to be closed down --
which has resulted in 47 million people being laid off -- and it tackled problems early.
All these are measures which Japan similarly had to make, but refused to do.
The result is that the Chinese economy works, while the Japanese economy
remains stalled, and China is becoming a leader in showing how Asia needs to evolve its
market economy, he said.
Rivers of investment flowing into China have made much of this possible,
of course, but Mr Overholt said investors are not just going to China because wages are
low. It is the ability of the Chinese government to reform its markets, open them to
competition and making things work that is attracting investors.
This has led to US$309 billion in foreign direct investment being pumped
into China in the 1990s, compared to just US$39 billion in Japan.
"There is a cloud along with the sliver lining," Mr Overholt warns, "and that is if
Japanese reform doesn't get underway soon, the economic environment in Asia is just going
to be awful for years and years.
"I hope that doesn't happen, but the risk is rising by the hour and
we have to be prepared for that."
You can listen to Mr Overholts
entire speech and many of those from the Venture Capital Partnership Conference on the
Chamber's Web site at: http://www.chamber.org.hk/info/speech/chamber_in_action_vc.asp |