i-PERKIN
December 2001 Issue

Zeroing in on "zero" interest
Local banks may not be able to avoid the "zero" rate option
much longer as fed hints it may cut U.S. rates further
By IAN PERKIN
Most Hong Kong banks dropped their
listed savings deposit and lending rates by 0.25 per cent in early November, taking the
basic savings deposit rate in most cases to just 0.25 per cent and the banks ¡¦ best lending rate to around 5.25 per cent.
As the U.S. central
bank, the Federal Reserve Board, had just cut its own federal funds rate by 0.5 per cent
to 2 per cent, the local Hong Kong banks just managed to avoid the "zero" savings rate option by making a lesser cut
than did "the fed."
With local monetary policy tied to that of the U.S. through Hong Kong's
linked exchange rate to the US-dollar, the local banks may not be able to avoid the
"zero" rate option much
longer, as the fed has hinted it may cut U.S. rates further.
In its commentary on its November 6 rate cut -- the tenth so far this
year, reducing the short-term federal funds rate by 4.5 per cent since January -- the fed
indicated that it was still worried more about a weaker U.S. economy than higher
inflation.
"Heightened uncertainty and concerns about a deterioration in
business conditions both here and abroad are damping economic activity," it said.
"For the foreseeable future, then, the [Federal Open Market]
Committee continues to believe that, against the background of its long-run goals of price
stability and sustainable economic growth and of the information currently available, the
risks are weighted mainly toward conditions that may generate economic weakness.
"Although the necessary reallocation of resources to enhance security
may restrain advances in productivity for a time, the long-term prospects for productivity
growth and the economy remain favourable and should become evident once the unusual forces
restraining demand abate."
This suggests there could be further rate cuts as early as December.
For Hong Kong savers, this is, of course, bad news. They have already seen
the basic savings deposit rate fall from 4.35 per cent at the start of the year to its
present level to 0.25 per cent. This cuts their earnings and is a major disincentive to
save -- provided there are relatively safe alternative investments available.
For potential borrowers, however, the lower rates are a major benefit,
with banks now offering loans for many purposes (but especially housing mortgages) at well
below their published best lending rates.
The problem on the borrowing side is not the availability of funds, or
their price (the going interest rate), but the demand. Confidence in the economy remains
extremely low and until it returns in some strength, borrowers are likely to remain
scarce.
Yet another factor that needs to be taken into account is that, with
continuing price deflation, "real" Hong Kong SAR interest rates remain fairly high by recent historical
standards. This fact could also be putting off potential borrowers.
Nominal interest rates in Hong Kong, whether for deposits, or on the
lending side, are certainly the lowest on record. For "real" (inflation or deflation adjusted) rates,
however, it is a far different story.
During the boom period from the early to the mid-1990s, Hong Kong
borrowers became used to sharply negative "real" (or inflation adjusted) interest rates. This was one of the factors
that helped fuel the boom in property and shares up to 1997.
But for most the period from the onset of the East Asian financial crisis
in late-1997, Hong Kong has been experiencing consumer price deflation (and especially
property price deflation) and this has meant the real cost of money has been high.
This has put off many borrowers and continues to do so. Why borrow at even
low nominal interest rates when deflation may continue and there is widespread concern
about the economy and the future of both property and share prices?
This is the bind the local economy finds itself in. It will also be a
difficult situation to get out of until there is a distinct turnaround in the U.S. and
global economies and a consequent improvement in the prospects for the Hong Kong SAR.
Looked at from this historical perspective, the current levels of real --
as opposed to nominal -- interest rates in Hong Kong have a long way to go before they are
the lowest on record.
Right now, after taking account of price deflation, the real Hong Kong
dollar savings deposit rate is still 1.25 per cent plus, and the best lending rate is more
than 5.5 per cent.
Back in the early- to mid-1990s, on the other hand, Hong Kong was looking
at "real" interest
rates (based on the simple rule of thumb of nominal rates discounted for consumer price
inflation) of a negative 4 per cent for the best lending rate.
For savings, the negative "real" rate sometimes got as low as 8 per cent.
The difference between then and now is that back then in the boom years up
to 1997 Hong Kong had significant levels of inflation (whether measured by the consumer
price index or anything else) and now it continues to suffer from the phenomena of
consumer price deflation.
For better economic times to return it is going to take perhaps more
interest rate cuts (which will pose an interesting problem for the banks with nominal
deposit rates already close to zero). But these will not be enough by themselves.
It is also going to take a pretty quick turn around in the U.S. and global
economies and a resurgence of confidence amongst local consumers and investors to get
things moving again. |