COVER STORY
December 2001 Issue

The great 'China Gold
Rush'
Now that China has been admitted into the
WTO, what lies ahead, and what should Hong Kong businesses be doing?
After 15 years of tough negotiations and seemingly constant dispute, the
142 World Trade Organisation (WTO) members' vote in Doha, Qatar, on November 11 to admit China to their ranks was greeted
with excitement and anticipation, but also with a pinch of anxiety.
HKGCC Chairman Christopher Cheng said he believes that the Mainland's
entry into the world trade body will provide a strong impetus to revitalise the weakening
economy in Hong Kong as well as in Asia.
"The events of September 11 in the United States have adversely
impacted the U.S. economy, and that of the global economic environment, including Hong
Kong. But China's entry -- and Taiwan's accession -- into the WTO will undoubtedly serve
as a catalyst that will help put Hong Kong's weakening economy back on track," he said. "China's entry will boost its
exports, while Taiwan's accession will accelerate direct links across the strait. We
expect that the local economy will benefit from this economic environment and help improve
our economic outlook for the coming year."
China's Foreign Trade Minister Shi Guangsheng said in his speech at the
4th Ministerial Conference in Doha, that China's WTO accession is not only in the interest
of China, but also in the interests of all WTO members.
"It will inevitably exert widespread and far reaching impact on
China's economy and on the world economy in the new century," he said.
He also challenged the organisation to establish 'a fair, just and
reasonable international economic new order' that would deliver more of globalisation's benefits to developing
countries.
While the general consensus that the impact Minister Shi is talking about
will be mostly win-win, it will most likely see-saw through economic ups and downs.
Under WTO rules, China's protective trade barriers are to be gradually
dismantled over the next several years in areas ranging from agriculture to
telecommunications.
A key question for China is whether the Central Government can get
regional provinces and municipalities to honour the rules imposed by the WTO. Foreign
businesses operating in China, however, say the government is working hard to bring its
regulations more into line with international commercial standards.
David Tso, chief executive, Hong Kong & South China, 7-Eleven
Division, The Dairy Farm Co. Ltd, said at the Chamber's October 29 WTO Workshop on Retail
& Distribution, that the Central Government has started to speed up the relaxation of
the rules.
"Using my own example, I just received our first convenience store
license from Beijing three months ago after two years. Due to government restructuring,
I'm sure this process will be speeded up," he said.
Although China is moving steadily toward a more open system, this does not
mean the Mainland market will be barrier-free, said International Trade Consultant Leora
Blumberg. Speaking at the Chamber's WTO Workshop on the Trading Sector, Ms Blumberg said
new hurdles, such as anti-dumping barriers, could be shored up to protect industries
facing competition from imports.
The Three Links
Taiwan's entry to the WTO, under the name 'Separate Customs Territory of
Taiwan, Kinmen and Matsu,' is not
expected to dilute Hong Kong's role as the key gateway for Taiwanese businesses investing
in the Mainland.
Wang Lu-yen , president, Roly International Group, said he expects the
lowering of trade barriers under WTO rules will have little impact on Taiwans trade with
the Mainland. The most significant factor, however, will be Taiwan's decision to support
businessmen investing in the Mainland.
Previously, Taiwanese businessmen were forced to 'hide' their business activities in the Mainland due
to the Taiwan government's restrictions on investment, which made it very difficult to get
support from banks.
"Now the Taiwan government is saying Taiwan banks can do business
with the Bank of China, and companies can even borrow money to do business in China," he said at the Chamber's November 15
roundtable luncheon on the establishment of the three links. "This will have a
tremendous impact on investment in China."
Even with easier access to capital, Mr Wang said he believes Taiwanese
businessmen will still find it to their advantage to go through Hong Kong.
Using his own business as an example, he said he had set up several
offices around Asia, but the most successful one has been Hong Kong, which now houses his
company's headquarters.
"Hong Kong, in my eyes, is still very valuable, and I think it will
still be the gateway to China for the Taiwanese," he said.
One hidden benefit which few people talk about is that by using Hong Kong
as a financial centre, companies can keep their profits in confidential accounts here and
take advantage of sophisticated financial tools, he said.
Regarding direct links across the Taiwan Strait, Mr Wang said that despite
many people heralding the move as a major saving for businesses, the estimated
cost-savings will hardly make a dint in companies' expenses.
Moreover, the majority of Taiwanese visiting the Mainland take the bus
directly from Hong Kong airport into the heart of the Pearl River Delta, and very few
actually take connecting flights.
"So Hong Kong will still be the preferred gateway into the Mainland
for the Taiwanese," he said.
Free Trade Agreement
Establishing a regional free trade agreement with the Mainland would help
Hong Kong gain some advantage over competing economies and increase its attractiveness for
companies to continue doing business with China through Hong Kong, while remaining within
WTO rules.
"A regional trade agreement between the Mainland and Hong Kong would
provide a head start for Hong Kong business before full implementation of China's WTO
accession commitments according to agreed-to timetables kick in. That would be permissible
under WTO rules and would be in accordance with the one country, two systems' principle," Chamber Director Dr Eden Woon said.
A speech in October by the Beijing Mayor, which was misreported by the
Hong Kong media as 'granting special preferential treatment to Hong Kong companies,' raised the hopes among Hong Kong businesses
that they would get a head start. But the mayor's quotes were misinterpreted and Central
Government officials have reiterated several times that Hong Kong companies should not ask
for special treatment because this would be against WTO rules.
However, a regional trade agreement would give Hong Kong an advantage --
in much the same way the North America Free Trade Agreement gives its members an advantage
-- while remaining within WTO rules.
The China Gold rush
Many companies that have successfully set up shop in China feel its entry
into the WTO will make doing business in the world's most populous nation easier. But they
point out it will be no picnic.
Ernst & Young Chief Operating Officer Marshall Byres likens the number
of companies heading for China to the California Gold Rush.
"There is gold over there. There is no question about that. It is a
huge country. The largest emerging market that has ever been seen. And if we, sitting in
Hong Kong, don't put ourselves out to get a bit of it, then we have been very silly," he told the audience at the Chamber's
November 5 WTO Workshop on Professional Services.
But just as thousands of prospectors heading for California fell by the
wayside or returned home broke, he warns not everyone going to China will strike it rich.
One tantalising aspect of China's WTO entry is that it gives companies the
right to start up a business on their own, instead of having to invest with a Mainland
partner. But Mr Byres said to do so would be total madness.
"You need to engage local people to become your partners in every
sense, psychologically, emotionally and financially. With local knowledge and local
guanxi, you can add your international knowledge and capability that you have developed
here in Hong Kong," he said.
Horror stories of foreign investors getting into bed with Mainland
partners that can't live up to their side of the bargain abound, he said. But so do
success stories.
As with any investment, due-diligence and careful planning are crucial. Mr
Byres said stories of negative deals should not discourage investors.
"If you have not yet taken that first step, I would encourage you to
do so now," he said.
Chamber WTO study
To help businesses prepare for China's WTO entry, HKGCC released its
report, 'China's Entry into the WTO and the Impact on Hong Kong Business,' in January last year. In the report, HKGCC
pointed out that the Hong Kong business community will need to cope with challenges
expected to arise from the new business environment, yet for ambitious entrepreneurs,
China's entry into the WTO would definitely create many new business opportunities.
"In the one-and-a-half years following the release of the report --
which we periodically update -- Hong Kong enterprises have been taking measures to prepare
for the challenges and opportunities ahead," Dr Woon said. "In September we began a series of nine industry
specific workshops which updated members on current developments within their sector. We
are also planning to conduct follow-up workshops which will look at China-Hong Kong WTO
issues in greater detail."
The Chamber also launched recently a 'China WTO Corner' on its Web site (www.chamber.org.hk)
to provide members with the latest information, business opportunities and activities
regarding China's entry into the WTO. Moreover, its 8th Annual Hong Kong Business Summit
on December 13 entitled, 'Hong Kong 2002: The First Year of China WTO,' will present an on-the-ground assessment of
the WTO question.
"With such resources, we are confident that the local business sector
can be kept up to date on issues affecting their businesses and be in a position to adapt
to the on-going economic changes to create unprecedented business opportunities," Dr Woon said. |