Advertise
In the Bulletin
|
COVER STORY
August 2001 Issue

Hotel occupancy rate
stable
More visitors than ever are coming to Hong Kong, yet the territory's hoteliers
can find little to cheer about
By Simon Ngan
Visitor arrivals are set to break all records
this year, with 14.07 million people expected visit Hong Kong, according to the Hong Kong
Tourist Board 's (HKTB) forecasts
made earlier this year. This prediction comes on the back of a record setting 15.3 per
cent increase last year, which saw 13.06 million visitors enter the territory.
Hoteliers are less than excited about these figures, however, because
while there is no doubt that more people are coming to Hong Kong, they are increasingly
staying for fewer days.
This is most clearly illustrated by the hotel rooms supply situation.
Between 1991 and 2000, the number of visitors to Hong Kong has doubled, from 6.79 million
to just over 13 million last year. Over this same period, the number of hotel rooms has
barely budged, from 31,163 in 1991 to 36,438 last year. Meanwhile, hotel occupancy rates
continued to average about 80 per cent.
What is more worrisome than not being able to increase the average
occupancy rate of 80 per cent over the past decade - despite a doubling of arrivals - is
that visitors are increasingly sensitive about how much they are willing to pay for a
hotel room.
If you were to check into a hotel in Hong Kong in 1991, the average room
rate would have been HK$672, or HK$1,017 in today 's money, according to HKTB's statistics. Last year, the average room rate was HK$683.
It is therefore understandable that despite such positive developments
with visitor arrivals, Hong Kong hoteliers have little to cheer about.
As Eric Waldburger,
CEO of Harbour Plaza Hotel Management, puts it, "From a statistical point of view, it is great and from a hotel
operator's perspective
[occupancy] can go higher but we will need to dump [rack] rates."
The plunge in visitors coming to Hong Kong during the Asian recession
forced hoteliers to ax their room rates to woo visitors. When the market showed signs of
picking up at the end of last year, hoteliers raised their rates a peg or two. Visitors
balked and forced the hotels to again lower their rates.
Signs of growth
Projections for growth in the industry over the next six to twelve months
range from neutral to negative growth tempered by cautious optimism with China 's WTO membership.
"If you look
at the last six months, I would say we are behind forecasts," said Alexander Jovanovic, resident manager Grand Hyatt. "All hotel categories have occupancy
levels that are 6 to 8 per cent lower than originally forecast."
A slowing European economy, recession in Japan and a weak U.S. market all
threaten to choke off growth in the hospitality sector. Top-tier hotels are likely to bear
the brunt of the latest downturn as businesses hunker down by travelling less frequently,
while tourists, although are travelling more frequently, are opting for cheaper
accommodation.
With lower prices and increasingly finicky visitors, hoteliers have been
handed the challenge of finding ways to win business. Hotels have responded by dropping
prices to attract customers and although reducing rates may sometimes be inevitable, Mr
Waldburger contends that there may be more creative ways to manage the process.
Measures
such as providing added-value services as incentives for travellers to stay at certain
hotels may prove to be more cost-effective.
Hotels in Hong Kong are already competing on this basis but have not been
met with much success. According to Mr Waldburger, this is because hotel promotions are
too frequent. He said that as simple as the rationale of gearing value-added packages
towards the practical needs of the customer might be, this is often overlooked by those in
the trade.
"When I am
on business, I appreciate a free glass of wine with my meal so that I don't have to buy a bottle. But how much do I eat
and drink when I am on business in this town. When everything moves at 200 miles per hour
you hardly find time. It doesn't
add value to my needs to have a free meal or drink," he said.
However, if a hotel can help a businessman reduce costs of doing business
while in Hong Kong, such as offering discounts on long distance calls, then such
added-value services would make more sense than a free glass of wine, he added.
Likewise, the Intercontinental Hotel tries to differentiate itself by
offering round-the-clock service to its clients.
"If you
check in at 2 a.m. in most hotels in the city and you ask for your suit to be pressed and
dry-cleaned, most will say "I'm sorry I cannot do that." We can do it and have it ready for you
for your 8 a.m. meeting," said
the hotel's manager, Tom Meyer.
Apart from fighting for market share, hoteliers are increasingly sensitive
about costs, which can be a delicate matter.
"Cost
management in this environment is inevitably something that a guest is going to discover.
If we changed something in the slightest that is going to be perceived by them to be a
qualitative change then we will be shooting ourselves in the foot quite literally," Mr Meyer pointed out.
Creativity and cost control strategies aside, among hoteliers ' greatest challenges under the present
conditions remains the ability to grow revenue.
Although occupancy levels have shown recovery, with the average hotel
occupancy last year being 83 per cent, compared to 80 per cent in 1999 and 76 per cent in
1998 - but still below the record 88 per cent in 1996 - this has not been quite matched by
hotel rates. This can be attributed to the growing importance of Mainland China, which
remains the leading source of visitors for four consecutive years with 3.78 million
arrivals last year, an impressive 18.1 per cent increase over 1999.
Hotels have generally been unable to benefit from this influx because
Chinese visitors represent a highly price-sensitive segment of international travellers.
To be sure, visitors from China continue to be the biggest contributor to visitor
spending, but taken in context of money spent on lodgings, this accounts for a mere 15.6
per cent of total spending as a group. Japanese visitors, on the other hand, spent 25.9
per cent on hotels in 2000 while American arrivals allocated 45.8 per cent in this regard.
At a time when hoteliers are having to fight harder for a slice of the
pie, many find it difficult to resist the institutional imperative to lower rates in a bid
to attract more guests. But this approach has been criticised as being short-sighted and
damaging to the health of the industry.
"When we have a business and people only
come here when we are down and out and on sale, you just cannot do business like that," said Joachim Burger, managing director,
Mega Hotels.
One way out of this would be for operators and owners to once and for all
agree within the various categories of hotels not to lower rates below a certain level,
suggests Mr Waldburger.
"The
customer would have to accept that they are paying such a price for a 3-, 4- or 5-star
hotel and that it won't get any
lower. They will still come to Hong Kong but at a price. A reasonable, fair and but not an
over inflated price," he
said.
While competing with each other, Hong Kong 's hoteliers should also work more closely to promote Hong Kong as a
destination.
"Compared to
products overseas, we have an excellent product here. But we are too lenient in giving it
away at a lower price. If we continue to operate like this, we will never be able to
recover to a healthy rate situation which is regrettable," Mr Waldburger said. |
|
|