The up-tick in real growth last year owes too much to falling prices,
writes DAVID O'REAR
Back in the dark recesses of history, before war, pneumonia and face
masks, Hong Kong's economy was beginning to show signs of life, growing faster each
quarter for 15 months running. The improvements were in both nominal and real terms, and
-- before "atypical economics" emerged -- pointing to an end to deflation.
Sadly, that is looking less and less likely this year.
The first two months of 2003 were solid performers, particularly on the
trade front where two-way commerce grew nearly 20 percent over January-February 2002. As a
trade and financial services oriented economy, the foundations looked good. But, loss of
consumer confidence, visitors staying away in droves, delays in moving goods and
passengers through our port and unpredictable shifts in retail sales will all take their
toll.
As the most international city in the world, we are at the mercy of forces
beyond our control. From the Asian Financial Crisis to the dot.com bubble, September 11,
war in the Middle East and now a pneumonia epidemic, our resilience has been tested. With
luck, the current challenges will prove short-lived.
Hong Kong's gross domestic product (GDP) rose 2.3 percent in real terms
last year, nearly four times the 0.6 percent rise recorded in 2001. However, all of the
rise -- and then some -- was due to deflation. Positive nominal growth of 0.6 percent in
the second half simply wasn't enough to overcome the 2 percent drop in January-June. The
chart on the right shows growth in nominal and real GDP.
The economy contracted 0.7 percent in nominal terms last year, the fifth
decline in seven years. Since 1997 -- notable for the on-set of the Asian financial crisis
in this analysis, not the handover -- the economy has cumulatively lost 4 percent of its
value. Yet, the mix of what's up and what's down tells a different story. Since 1997,
consumer spending has dropped 11.3 percent, but government consumption spending (largely
salaries) is up 15.5 percent. Services exports rose 20.8 percent over five years, but
capital investment fell by 31.7 percent. The second chart shows the difference, over five
years, in price changes for the private and public consumption.
The trend continues. While private consumption and capital investment both
fell back into the red in real terms (dropping 1.3 percent and 5.2 percent, respectively)
in 2002, government spending (up 3 percent), exports (up 8.8 percent) and imports (up 6.4
percent) combined to keep real GDP on the rise.
Fourth quarter growth of 5 percent, over October-December 2001, was the
strongest in two years. Most notable was a 0.5 percent rise in investment, the first since
the third quarter of 2001. Excluding changes in inventories, GDP expanded for the 14th
straight quarter, at a 3 percent pace.
In nominal terms, GDP contracted 0.7 percent, the fourth drop in five
years. Private consumption expenditure, equal to 61.9 percent of domestic demand, fell 5
percent during the year, the sharpest fall on record. October-December's 5.9 percent
decline in domestic demand was the worst in four years, reflecting the continued lack of
consumer confidence amid steady deflation.
Two-way trade, which is 3.2 times as large as domestic demand, rose 4.5
percent in nominal terms during 2002, backed by a 6 percent rise in goods and services
exports (up 5.4 percent and 8.8 percent, respectively) and a 3 percent rise in overall
imports. Merchandise imports expanded 3.4 percent during the year while services bought
from abroad contracted 0.5 percent.
Prices, as measured by various deflators derived from the national
accounts, continued to fall. The GDP deflator fell 2.9 percent for the full year, with the
fourth quarter's disappointing 3.8 percent drop the worst in nine quarters and the 18th
straight drop. Despite a long-awaited contraction in the government consumption
expenditure (GVT) deflator -- a proxy for the size and cost of the bloated civil service
-- which fell 2.6 percent in the final quarter of the year, the GVT price indicator rose
0.2 percent last year.
Goods and services export prices fell 2.9 percent last year, but eased to
just a 2 percent fall in the fourth quarter. Merchandise imports and exports have fallen
in price for 27 straight quarters -- predating the Asian financial crisis -- by more than
a year. During that time, import prices fell a cumulative 17 percent while export prices
dropped 14 percent.
After taking into account a 0.7 percent rise in the population, GDP per
capita totaled HK$187,571 (US$24,048) last year. That is about on par with the United
Kingdom and higher than the average among Euro-zone nations, at least prior to the fall in
the US dollar in recent months.
David O'Rear is the Chamber's Chief Economist. He can be reached at david@chamber.org.hk