Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce
Click here to login e-Club  Click here to visit our Chinese frontpage

Advertise
In the Bulletin

From the Chairman

Legco Report

From the Director

Cover Story
Economics: The Steve Forbes way

Special Feature  Asia's Catwalk

i-Perkin 
Hong Kong on the rebound from the global slowdown?

Budget 2002-03 
No nasty surprises from the Financial Secretary

Face to Face

With Deborah Annells

Business
Mainland/Hong Kong Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement

Service level agreements -- The IT service providers' success platform

Chamber Programmes
Annual Spring Dinner


ARCHIVES

2009 Issues
2008 Issues
2007 Issues
2006 Issues
2005 Issues
2004 Issues
2003 Issues
2002 Issues
2001 Issues
2000 Issues
1999 Issues

Search for

 
Advanced Search

SUBSCRIBE TO THE BULLETIN TODAY!

BUSINESS                                                                   April  2002 Issue


theBulletin.gif (2057 bytes)



Service level agreements
The IT service providers' success platform

sla1.jpg (13460 bytes)Service level agreements can be reformed from static documents to platforms of success if properly prepared
By ANGUS FORSYTH and YVONNE CHIA

The wider adoption of e-commerce, corresponding sophistication of IT infrastructure and the present global economic downturn have sharpened customers' expectations and intensified competition for IT service providers. Althoughsla2.jpg (13088 bytes) service level agreements (SLAs) are simply a type of contract between service providers and their customers to identify the agreed services to be provided and their respective responsibilities, properly prepared SLAs can be a service providers' platform to success.

The true value of SLAs lies in the two-way communication involved in their preparation, which allows customers to think through and voice their needs to service providers to supply what is demanded. Deliberative customisation is an important differentiator of services and often builds customer loyalty.

SLAs -- issues to consider & temptations to resist

Service providers should carefully analyses their capabilities, expertise and infrastructure when drafting SLAs. They must also assess how their resources can be best allocated in view of customers' business objectives, technical support requested, existing infrastructure, scope and level of services, application timetable and costs.

It is important to resist giving attractive promises which would be difficult to deliver -- the time when such temptation didn't matter is now long gone -- but attractive promises can be included if watered down by strings of small print exemption clauses.

Exemptions clauses of SLAs -- Hong Kong judicial & statutory positions

Under common law, the following three ingredients must be baked into an exemption-clauses pie: incorporated into the contract; properly and fully construed, covers the damage caused; and there is no other rule of law which invalidates the exemption clause.

The effect of the general judicial "contra proferentem" rule of construction is that ambiguity is construed against the party seeking to rely on the clause. As a brief guideline, the following hurdles must be overcome before terms are incorporated:

i    notice of terms given at or before conclusion of contracts;

ii    terms are contracted in a document intended to have contractual effect; and

iii    reasonable steps have been taken by the party seeking to rely on the terms to bring them to the attention of the other party. Generally, the more unusual the exemption, the more prominent it must be to constitute sufficient notice. For onerous exemptions, judges have indicated that they need to be printed in red ink with a red hand pointing to it.

Under Hong Kong law, the Control of Exemption Clauses Ordinance (Cap. 71) (the "Or-dinance") controls the extent to which liability can be limited or excluded for negligence and breach of contract.

In short, the Ordinance renders certain types of exemption clauses totally void, such as clauses excluding or restricting liability for death or personal injury resulting from neglig-ence. It also requires certain exemption clauses satisfy the "reasonableness" test to be proved by the person invoking the clause, e.g. clauses excluding or restricting liability for negligence other than negligence causing death or personal injury.

SLA markers

SLAs, like any other contracts, must constitute full records of parties' intentions. Typical components of a SLA include:

Identification of Parties & Recitals

-       Due diligence of the customer entities (e.g. conduct company
      searches and enquires who has real shareholding control) is
      recommended especially if service providers have no previous
      dealings with them.

Service Terms

-         Particulars of services ("IT Services") and completion dates
        should be confirmed with the customer and fully detailed in a
        work schedule attached to the SLA.

-         Request customer to provide accurate materials and data
        necessary for service providers to provide the IT Services and
        guide the customer into perfecting this.

-         Provide mechanism for changing the IT Services to
        accommodate changes in governmental regulations or safety
        standards.

-         If system specifications are relevant, what is the effect of
        their alteration?

-         What is the consequence of a system fault affecting quality
        or preventing delivery?

Payment Terms

-         Does the payment schedule tie in with the completion
        schedule?

-         Billing frequency.

-         Payment of applicable taxes or surcharges to be borne by
        the customer.

-         Default interest.

-         What are the basis of charges? Are they performance
        related?

-         Insurance.

-         Ability of the service providers to sub-contract their
        obligations.

Intellectual Property

-         All information and data given by the SP relating to the IT
        Services belong to the service provider subject to the
        customer's use to utilise the IT Services.

-         Are the IP rights of work done for the customer assigned
        to him?

Warranties

-         Information provided by each party will not infringe any third
        party IP rights.

-         What are the compliance performance standards and their
        monitoring tools?

-         The extent of application of implied warranties should be
        considered, in particular, the effectiveness of such exclusion
        clauses under the governing legal jurisdiction of the SLA. As
        mentioned, liability arising from negligence causing death or
        personal injury cannot be excluded under Hong Kong law.

-         Is the service providers' liability capped? Exclusions for
        different types of damages should be considered.

Duration and Validity of Agreement

-         What is the duration of the SLA and can the term be
        extended?

-         What are the termination events and notice period?

"Boiler Plate"

For example, notices, force majeure and entire agreement provisions.

Applicable Law and Mode of Dispute Resolution

-       Is the dispute resolution by means of arbitration or court
      proceedings? The choice of governing law and jurisdiction
      should be selected having considered, inter alia, the parties'
      places of incorporation and principal places of business. If
      arbitration is chosen as the principal mode of dispute
      resolution, the situs and the governing arbitration rules should
      be stated.

With the multi-jurisdictional nature of e-commerce, special care should be given to jurisdictional issues and areas of conflict of laws which are beyond the scope of this article. The writers would like to point out, however, that parties should think through how IP rights, which are generally granted on a geographical/jurisdictional basis, can be protected and enforced where different jurisdictions are likely to be involved. Although international difficulties with this problem are causing it to be examined worldwide, there is no real progress towards even a reduced series of credible options and it remains a very complex area on which specific advice should be sought.

SLM and corporate governance

Service level management (SLM), not SLAs, is the ultimate platform for success. Even though service providers have worked out the best solution for the customer and reached an agreed quality standard as documented in SLAs, this is only the beginning. Under the corporate governance discipline of the SLM umbrella, the service providers must now deliver what they have promised.

A structured and efficiently backlit SLM will enable business to provide quality service. This is done by proactively operating constant service level monitoring to spot problems. Properly implemented, this automatically activates the corresponding change mechanism to restore the due quality. SLM also systematically determines what caused problems and, better still, manages service factors to avoid potential problems.

SLM creates defined and repeatable processes for service improvements and a speedy remedy. The remedial work will, in turn, impact on the service providers' overall capacities and corresponding adjustment and need for additional resources should be drawn to the management's attention to ensure performance of service providers' other services are not adversely affected. Corporate governance is intrinsically wedded to SLM and represents the top level, directional glue that melds together the disparate components of shaping the management style, corporate culture, core competency and, lastly, ensuring operational excellence.

Angus Forsyth and Yvonne Chia are with IT Practice Group of Stevenson,
Wong & Co. (Web site: www.sw-hk.com)

About HKGCC | Member Services | Join Us | Contact Us | Advertising | Jobs
The Chamber's Privacy Policy Statement
Copyright © 1998-2009 The Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce. All Rights Reserved.