FACE TO FACE
April
2002 Issue

Face to Face
with Asia-Africa Committee Chairman Deborah Annells
The era of the Asian Tigers is over, at least for the short term, as the
region's economies limp along and foreign direct investment continues to be funnelled into
Mainland China. Analysts predict China's surging
economic growth will add some strain to Asia's struggling economies but this is expected
to favor the region in the long term. Bulletin Editor Malcolm Ainsworth spoke with
the Chamber's Asia-Africa Committee Chairman, Deborah Annells, about the region's
prospects. Following are excerpts from that interview.
China is enjoying
unprecedented popularity as a place for foreign companies to invest. Where does that leave
Asian nations?
Of course many Asian nations are the ones who are investing in China,
because they use China for cheap manufacturing also. Take Japan, for example, or Taiwan,
and of course Hong Kong, a substantial part of our manufacturing has moved into China. I
think it makes everybody more prosperous. As the world is also becoming more
international, it is not just the Americans and Europeans who are using China for
manufacturing nowadays, it is also other Asian nations.
Are they in danger of
hollowing out their economies?
Not at all. They are only using China for particular purposes, like
manufacturing. We all hear of the story of there being 300,000 to 400,000 Taiwanese living
in Shanghai, but what are they doing? They are primarily manufacturing computer bits,
chips, wafers and so forth, so the wealth that they generate from doing business there
ultimately still trickles back to Taiwan.
Do you think the string
of political scandals in the region, rather than China and recession, has led to
international investors losing interest in Asia?
I think transparency has always been an issue in this region. People who
live and work here understand the issues, but from afar, the way that markets work is not
entirely clear, so I think some scandals have probably affected how international
investors use this region.
What do you think Asian
nations need to do to regain their roar?
I think all of them have to be more
transparent than they were. If they can get their political systems back into order, they
will then regain credibility. People on the ground will also have to go up the value
chain. They are no longer cheap manufacturing jurisdictions, now China is. So therefore,
to take advantage of this, Asian personnel have to move up the value chain, as we are
doing in Hong Kong.
How has rising interest
in China affected the Asia-Africa Committee?
It is true to say that our numbers have diminished slightly, but also the
size of the China Committee has increased. But it is also a reflection that Asian
companies are deploying fewer personnel in Hong Kong, and so obviously send fewer numbers
of their staff to attend our meetings. That said, we still attract a lot of interest
through our high quality events, and I must say all our meetings are very informative and
very good -- people who attend our meetings always enjoy them and learn something. So that
has to be a good sign.
You organized some very
interesting missions last year, to Myanmar and North Korea, for example. How successful
were they?
The irony here is that successful trade missions tend to be to countries
that are difficult to visit or are opening up, say Myanmar or North Korea. So people are
interested to see what is going on there, but it is actually very difficult, still, to go
and establish a business or business contact there. While I think the missions were very
successful, that doesn't mean lots of trade resulted immediately from those visits, but
hopefully that will come in due course.
What is the committee
planning for the next 12 months?
We aim to have something happening every month. We have our committee
meetings where we have a guest speaker speaking about something topical -- our last talk
was about the Japanese yen, so that was very interesting. We have a full schedule lined up
for the first half of this year, including a fellowship evening, so it is not all
information orientated, we are going to have a horse racing evening, for example. People
don't always just want information gathering exercises. The Chamber itself has been
holding cocktail evenings which have been very successful, and that is a good way of
mingling with and meeting other people.
You are very active in
the Chamber and hold a very responsible position as Vice President, Global Wealth
Structuring, at The Citigroup Private Bank, which must be demanding on your time. What do
you personally get out of investing so much of your time in the Chamber?
I think people underestimate the importance of having a chamber. I've
benefited tremendously from being a member of the Chamber. In the very beginning, I was a
deputy representative for someone, who in my original work, never came to meetings. He
always used to say, "Debbie, you go to the meeting for me," and so I just used
to turn up. Then I left that job and joined a new organization and I thought, gosh I still
want to belong to the Chamber! So I made them join, and I then joined the committee in my
own capacity. Then I was voted on as deputy chair and then as chair person. If I've
benefited tremendously from it, that is because I've put a lot into it as well. I think it
is quid pro quo: you put a lot in, you get a lot out. If you do nothing, you get nothing.
Also, you can access anyone in Hong Kong through the Chamber more easily
than any other way actually. And if you want to find something out you can find the answer
much more quickly. So to that extent the Chamber it is a tremendous enabling mechanism. |